Pros and Cons of a Short Sale in the LBI Real Estate Market

Short sales, foreclosures, and distressed sales on LBI can offer unique opportunities for buyers and much‑needed solutions for sellers, but they also come with added complexity. Each option has its own timeline, financial implications, and condition‑related challenges that require careful evaluation—especially with LBI’s coastal regulations, flood considerations, and renovation costs. Buyers may find value, but must be prepared for as‑is conditions and sometimes lengthy processes, while sellers need to consider credit impact and the best path forward. Understanding these dynamics is essential to making informed decisions in any distressed situation on Long Beach Island.

​

​

Definitions at a Glance

​

• Short Sale: The lender agrees to accept a payoff less than the outstanding loan balance to allow a sale. The owner still holds title until closing.

• Foreclosure:

  • Sheriff Sale (Auction): The property is auctioned following a legal process when the owner defaults. Limited access and few contingencies.

  • REO (Real Estate Owned): The bank/lender acquires the home after it doesn’t sell at auction and lists it on the open market.

• Distressed Sale (Umbrella Term): Any sale driven by hardship or property condition (e.g., estate sale, storm damage, unfinished renovations, severe deferred maintenance) that motivates pricing or terms.

​​

Short Sale on LBI

​

How It Works (New Jersey & LBI Context)

• The owner lists the home subject to lender approval; the buyer and seller agree on terms, then the lender reviews the package (hardship letter, valuation, net sheet).

• Timelines vary widely—often 60–180+ days for lender decisions.

• Seller may still occupy the home through closing; showings are typically easier than foreclosure scenarios.

​

Pros & Cons for Sellers

​

Pros

• Less damaging to credit and public record than foreclosure.

• Potential for deficiency waiver (not guaranteed—must be negotiated).

• More control and dignity versus a forced sale; can coordinate move-out.

• May qualify for relocation assistance (“cash for keys”) from some lenders.

​

Cons

• Lender approval required—you can’t guarantee a closing date.

• The risk of a deficiency remains if the lender doesn’t waive the unpaid balance.

• Possible tax implications if forgiven debt is treated as taxable income (consult a CPA).

• Emotional and time burden—document-gathering, repeated updates, buyer attrition.

​

Pros & Cons for Buyers

​

Pros

• Potential below-market pricing, especially if the property needs work.

• More transparent access for inspections than auctions; can often secure mortgage financing.

• Chance to lock in a desirable location (oceanside, bayside, lagoon-front) that’s rarely discounted.

​

Cons

• Long approval timelines; the lender can counter on price or terms, or decline.

• Property sold as-is; lender unlikely to pay for repairs or credits.

• Risk of seasonal timing issues—a delayed approval could push closing past prime renovation or rental windows.

• Need for elevation/flood due diligence: Substantial improvement thresholds can trigger elevation requirements.

​

What to Check (Buyer Checklist)

• Current elevation certificate and flood zone; estimate flood insurance.

• Piling, foundation, and bulkhead (if waterfront) condition.

• Rental history and projected gross rental income (GRI) post-renovation.

• HOA or private road issues (if applicable), and any open permits/violations.

• Lender’s required addenda and as-is clauses.

​

Foreclosure on LBI (Sheriff Sale & REO)

​

Sheriff Sale (Auction)

​

Pros (Buyers)

• Potential for steep discounts if competition is light.

• Speed—closings (when you win) can be faster than short sales.

​

Cons (Buyers)

• Typically, no interior access before bidding; unknown condition.

• Often requires cash or hard money; little to no contingencies.

• You may inherit liens, municipal charges, or occupancy issues—title work is essential.

• No seller disclosure, and no repairs.

​

Who It Fits

• Experienced investors, contractors, or well-advised buyers with strong cash positions and risk tolerance.

​

REO (Bank-Owned)

​

Pros (Buyers)

• Market-listed with lockbox access; inspections usually permitted.

• The bank may allow financing and may clear most title issues pre-list.

• Sometimes eligible for bank credits or repair allowances (case-by-case).

​

Cons (Buyers)

• Still as-is with limited disclosures.

• Banks often price aggressively after early days on the market, with less discount than auctions.

• Multiple-offer situations are common in attractive LBI locations.

​

Pros & Cons for Sellers (Prior Owner)

• Once a property reaches foreclosure, the former owner loses control of sale timing and proceeds; credit impact and public record consequences are more severe than a short sale. Relocation support depends on the lender and situation.

​

Distressed Sales (Non-Lender-Driven Hardships)

​

Examples in the Long Beach Island Real Estate Market

• Estate/probate sales, storm-damaged properties, unfinished renovations, properties with prolonged deferred maintenance or code issues.

​

Pros (Sellers)

• Faster resolution than short sale/foreclosure; you set the terms.

• Potential for an as-is sale while still attracting buyers with the right pricing.

​

Cons (Sellers)

• Discounted pricing vs. improved comparables.

• May require pre-list prep (cleanout, minor safety items) to maximize interest.

• Inspection negotiations can still arise.

​

Pros (Buyers)

• Negotiation leverage on price and terms, especially if you can close quickly.

• Inspection access and typical financing options are more available than auctions.

• Opportunity to add value via elevation, reconfiguration, or rental-ready updates.

​

Cons (Buyers)

• Competition from cash buyers/contractors.

• Scope creep on renovations (salt-air, systems, structural surprises).

• Must align plans with local zoning, height, coverage, and FEMA compliance—especially if hitting the 50% substantial improvement threshold.

​

LBI-Specific Due Diligence (Don’t Skip These)

​

1. Flood & Elevation: Get the elevation certificate; model flood insurance scenarios now and post-renovation/elevation.

2. Structural & Pilings: Barrier island conditions can mask corrosion or settlement—hire inspectors/engineers with coastal experience.

3. Bulkhead/Waterfront: Age, height, and condition of bulkheads and docks matter for safety, insurance, and financing.

4. Utilities & Systems: HVAC, electrical, plumbing, and storm resilience (flood vents, equipment elevation) are critical.

5. Zoning & Building: Verify lot coverage, height limits, and setbacks before assuming expansion potential.

6. Insurance: Price flood, wind, and hazard insurance early; premiums can change project viability.

7. Seasonality: Time closing/renovations around the summer rental season to avoid losing high-ADR weeks if your plan involves STR income.

8. Rental Strategy: Analyze historical occupancy, GRI potential, and management—LBI rental demand is strong but varies by location and beach access.

​

Which Path Fits Your Situation?

​

• If you’re a Seller in Hardship

  • Prefer control and lower credit impact? Explore a short sale.

  • Need a faster, simpler exit and can price to market? Consider a distressed as-is listing.

  • Avoid letting the clock run to foreclosure—that’s typically the hardest outcome for your credit and future financing.

​

• If you’re a Buyer Seeking Value

  • Investor/Contractor with cash? Sheriff sales or heavy-fixers can pencil out.

  • Want inspections and financing? Focus on REO and short sales (but build in time for approvals).

  • New to LBI? A well-priced distressed listing with standard contingencies may offer the best balance of value + certainty.

​

Frequently Asked Questions About Short Sales Foreclosures and Distressed Sales in the LBI Real Estate Market

​

Do short sales close in time for summer?

Sometimes—but plan for delays. Build contingencies for lender approval timelines and consider off-season renovations.

​

Can I finance a short sale or REO on LBI?

Yes, depending on condition. Properties needing major work may require rehab loans (e.g., FHA 203(k), conventional renovation) or cash + later refinance.

​

Will a short sale wipe out my full mortgage balance?

Not automatically. Sellers should negotiate deficiency waivers and consult with an attorney/CPA about tax treatment of forgiven debt.

​

Do I get inspections on a sheriff sale?

Typically no. That’s why these purchases are best for experienced buyers with risk tolerance.

​

What’s the biggest surprise cost on LBI?

Often flood/elevation-related requirements and coastal wear (pilings, bulkheads, exterior systems). Plan conservative budgets.