Things to Do on LBI When It Rains in the Fall
- Nathan Colmer
- 2 days ago
- 3 min read
Rainy Day Adventures on Long Beach Island in the Fall
By Nathan Colmer
Discover the best things to do on Long Beach Island, NJ when it rains in the fall—from cozy cafés and coffee shops to local history and indoor shopping. Perfect for off-season visitors and LBI real estate explorers.
Long Beach Island (LBI) may be known for its sun-soaked beaches and bustling summer crowds, but when fall rolls in and the skies turn gray, the island reveals a quieter, cozier charm. Rainy days on Long Beach Island in autumn offer a perfect opportunity to explore LBI’s indoor gems, savor seasonal flavors, and enjoy the peaceful rhythm of island life.
By : Nathan Colmer | LBI Real Estate Agent | The Van Dyk Group
Cell: 609-290-4293 | Office: 800-222-0131 | ncolmer@vandykgroup.com
1. Visit the LBI Historical Museum
Located in Beach Haven, this charming museum offers a deep dive into the island’s rich maritime and cultural history. It’s a must-see for anyone interested in the heritage of Long Beach Island, especially on a rainy afternoon. You can also stop by the Maritime Museum located near Parker's Garage and Bird and Betty's for some more indoor history!
2. Cozy Up in a Local Café on Long Beach Island
Fall is the season for warm drinks and baked goods. Try Whittingham Coffee Shop in Beach Haven or How You Brewin? in Surf City for a relaxing afternoon with a latte and a good book.
3. Explore Local Art Galleries
Rainy days are perfect for discovering LBI’s creative side. The Crafts and Fine Arts Gallery in Loveladies and the M.T. Burton Gallery in Surf City showcase works from local artists that reflect the island’s coastal beauty and seasonal moods.
4. Catch a Show at Surflight Theatre
Even in the off-season, Surflight Theatre often hosts performances, concerts, and comedy nights. It’s a great way to enjoy live entertainment without braving the weather. Just make sure you check the schedule first and the number of shows drops off in the off-season!
5. Shop for Unique Finds
From boutique clothing stores to antique shops, LBI has plenty of indoor shopping options. Song of the Sea in Beach Haven and The Seawife in Barnegat Light offer coastal-inspired gifts and décor that make great souvenirs or home accents. There are still plenty of stores open in September and October on Long Beach Island, so be sure to stop in your favorites.
6. Enjoy a Fall-Inspired Meal
Rainy fall days call for comfort food. Head to The Old Causeway in Manahawkin for hearty fare or Black Whale Bar & Fish House in Beach Haven for fresh seafood in a cozy setting. Another personal favorite is the Dock and Claw on Centre Street in Beach Haven. It has a great vibe and great fall soups!
7. Take a Scenic Drive
Even if you can’t walk on the beach, you can still enjoy the views. Drive along Long Beach Boulevard and take in the quiet neighborhoods, marshlands, and bayfront homes that make LBI so special in the fall. Be sure to visit Barnegat Lighthouse and the Holgate preserve while you are at it!
Bonus Tip: Explore LBI Real Estate in the Off-Season
Fall is a fantastic time to explore Long Beach Island real estate. With fewer crowds and a slower pace, it’s easier to envision life on the island year-round. Whether you're looking for a cozy beach cottage or a bayfront escape, LBI offers a unique blend of charm, lifestyle, and investment potential.
By : Nathan Colmer | LBI Real Estate Agent | The Van Dyk Group
Cell: 609-290-4293 | Office: 800-222-0131 | ncolmer@vandykgroup.com
