
Long Beach Island Real Estate Sales Archive for Nathan Colmer
Nathan Colmer's LBI Real Estate Past Sale History
Over the past two decades, Nathan Colmer has built a consistent and data-driven track record as one of the most active real estate professionals serving the Long Beach Island market. With experience spanning multiple market cycles—including the pre-recession peak, the 2008 downturn, the post–Hurricane Sandy recovery, and the rapid appreciation of the 2020–2025 surge—his results reflect both adaptability and long-term market expertise.
Through changing conditions, Nathan has remained actively involved in transactions across all price points—from entry-level coastal properties to multi-million-dollar oceanfront homes—helping buyers, sellers, and investors navigate the Long Beach Island real estate market with confidence.

LBI NJ Home Sales by Year | Nathan Colmer Real Estate Track Record
My LBI real estate sales archive is designed to give you, the reader, a clear understanding of my experience in the LBI real estate market. Over the course of my career, I have sold more than 600 homes, totaling more than $750,000,000 in gross real estate sales. This record has given me extensive experience across all aspects of the LBI real estate market and enables me to deliver unmatched service to my clients. Here you can view:
-
Verified MLS sales organized by year
-
Clear record of transaction history across LBI
-
Coverage of oceanfront, bayfront, and oceanside, bayside, lagoon front, commercial, and every other aspect of the Long Beach Island real estate market.
-
View sales in all towns and areas of the LBI real estate market
-
See my past representation of buyers, sellers, or both in all price tiers and property styles
Each year represents a snapshot of real market activity, providing transparency and a clear representation of my ongoing involvement in the Long Beach Island real estate market.
Nathan Colmer's Career Total Long Beach Island Real Estate Production
Over 600 Buyer and Seller Transactions
Over $750,000,000 in Total Sales Volume









Nathan Comer's Long Beach Island Real Estate Sales Transactions
LBI New Jersey Real Estate
Long Beach Island is a highly competitive and dynamic coastal real estate market, where experience and consistency play a significant role in achieving successful outcomes. This sales archive documents real estate transactions handled by Nathan Colmer, offering a transparent and detailed look at past performance.
Each yearly page within this archive includes individual property sales with key details such as date, location, and sale price. This structured format allows buyers, sellers, and researchers to better understand how the market has evolved and how properties have performed over time.
Nathan Colmer has consistently been involved in residential real estate transactions throughout Long Beach Island, demonstrating familiarity with a wide range of property types, including oceanfront homes, bayside residences, and investment properties. These verified MLS sales highlight long-term participation in the market and an ability to navigate shifting conditions across both high-demand and transitional periods.
For homeowners considering selling, reviewing past transactions provides valuable context around pricing, demand, and positioning. For buyers, it offers a deeper understanding of the market landscape and historical activity across LBI’s most desirable locations.
Past LBI Real Estate Sales
View my past year's sales in the Long Beach Island real estate market. My 20+ years of selling LBI real estate market has made me one of the top producing agents on Long Beach Island year after year!
LBI Real Estate Single Family Homes
LBI New Jersey Real Estate
Long Beach Island Market Experience Across Changing Conditions
One of the biggest advantages you can have when buying or selling real estate on Long Beach Island is working with someone who has seen the market in all its phases—not just the strong years.
Over time, I’ve worked through very different types of markets:
2005–2007: A Strong, Fast-Paced Market
This was a period of high demand and rising prices, especially for oceanfront homes and second properties. Buyers were active and values were climbing quickly.
2008–2011: The Market Shift
After the financial crisis, things slowed down. Prices adjusted, deals took longer, and negotiations became a key part of almost every transaction.
2013–2016: Post–Hurricane Sandy Recovery
Following Hurricane Sandy, the market reset in many ways. Property values adjusted, inventory changed, and new opportunities opened up—especially for buyers and investors willing to step in early.
2020–2022: Unprecedented Demand
This was one of the strongest markets LBI has ever seen. Low inventory and high demand pushed prices to new highs, and many properties sold quickly with multiple offers.
2023–Today: A More Balanced Market
Today’s market still has strong demand—especially for premium properties—but things have leveled out a bit. Pricing is higher than ever, but buyers are more selective and strategic.
Experience Across All Property Types in the LBI Real Estate Market
Over the years, I’ve worked across just about every type of property on Long Beach Island
-
Oceanfront homes – High-end properties with top-tier pricing and demand
-
Oceanblock & oceanside homes – Always in demand and a core part of the LBI market
-
Bayside properties – Great opportunities for value and long-term investment
-
Single-family homes – The backbone of the market across all price ranges
-
Condos and townhomes – Popular for investors and first-time buyers
-
New construction & redevelopment – Opportunities to create long-term value
Local Knowledge Across Long Beach Island
I’ve had the opportunity to work with clients all across Long Beach Island and nearby coastal communities, including:
-
Long Beach Township
-
Beach Haven
-
Surf City
-
Ship Bottom
-
Harvey Cedars
-
Barnegat Light
-
Holgate
-
Mainland areas nearby
Working across the entire island gives me a real-time understanding of pricing, demand, and what makes each area unique.
Choosing the right real estate agent on Long Beach Island comes down to experience, strategy, and execution—not just listing access.
Over the years, I’ve worked through every type of market LBI has experienced—from the pre-2008 surge and downturn, to the post-Sandy reset, to the record-breaking run of the past few years, and today’s more balanced but still competitive environment. That perspective allows me to help clients make smart decisions no matter what the market is doing.
I’ve handled everything from entry-level condos to multi-million-dollar oceanfront homes, and that range matters. Whether you're buying your first place on the island or selling a high-end property, the strategy needs to match the situation—and I tailor it accordingly.
What You Get Working With Me:
-
Full-cycle market experience
-
You’re working with someone who understands not just how to transact, but how markets move—and how to position you within them.
-
Strong negotiation and deal execution
-
Contracts, inspections, pricing adjustments—this is where deals are won or lost. I stay hands-on throughout the entire process.
-
Real local insight—not generic data
-
Every section of LBI is different. I help you understand where the value is today and where it’s heading.
-
Access to opportunities others don’t see
-
From off-market properties to well-timed listings, knowing what’s coming—and when to act—is a major advantage.
-
A long-term perspective
Whether you're buying, selling, or investing, the goal is not just the transaction—it’s making a smart move that holds up over time.
Nathan Colmer
C: 609-290-4293 O: 609-492-1511 Email Me
If you’re considering buying or selling property on Long Beach Island, having a clear understanding of past market activity is a powerful advantage. With a proven record of verified MLS sales and consistent involvement in the LBI real estate market, Nathan Colmer offers the experience and insight needed to help you make informed decisions.
Explore the sales archive above, and when you're ready, connect directly to discuss your goals, property value, or opportunities in today’s market.


